We propose a difference-in-differences (DiD) approach to estimate the impact of incentives on cost reduction. We show theoretically, and estimate empirically, that German electricity distribution system operators (DSOs) incur higher costs when subject to a lower-powered regulation mechanism. The difference is particularly significant (about 7%) for firms in the upper quartile of the efficiency distribution, a pattern which is consistent with the pooling of types under the threat of ratcheting.

Hellwig, Michael, Dominik Schober und Luis Cabral (2018), Incentive Regulation: Evidence from German Electricity Networks, ZEW Discussion Paper No. 18-010, Mannheim. Download


Hellwig, Michael
Schober, Dominik
Cabral, Luis


Regulation, ratchet effect, electricity utilities, difference-in-differences, efficiency analysis