Domestic Patents Strengthen China's Technological Independence

Research

ZEW Study Analyses the Origin and Quality of Chinese Innovation

In recent years, China has replaced the USA as the world’s leading patent nation. However, while the number of patent applications continues to rise, the average contribution of a Chinese patent to innovation is declining – as is the growth rate of top patents, which are crucial for technological progress. At the same time, domestic inventions are increasingly shaping the direction of innovation in China. This is shown by a recent study conducted by ZEW Mannheim in cooperation with the University of Toronto, the Central University of Finance and Economics in Beijing and Goethe University Frankfurt. This development has implications for China’s economic growth and reveals potential effects of Chinese policy.

“The contribution of foreign knowledge – especially from the USA – to Chinese innovation has recently declined significantly. This points to growing independence on the part of China,” explains Professor Philipp Boeing, co-author of the study and researcher in the ZEW Research Unit “Economics of Innovation and Industrial Dynamics.” “While patent applications from abroad and applications from foreign-invested enterprises in China now account for only a small share, the majority of applications to the Chinese Patent Office come from Chinese private companies and universities. For comparison: In China, the share of foreign patent applications was recently just 10 per cent – whereas in the USA it is around 50 per cent.”

Quality of top patents declining

The analysis also shows that the contribution of individual Chinese patents to technological progress is continuously decreasing, accompanied by a higher volume of patents and greater specialisation. While the number of high-quality patents, which are decisive for technological progress, continues to increase, their growth rate is declining. These developments partly reflect global trends in the decline of innovativeness as well as the patent strategies of other countries. A direct comparison shows, for example, that more than half of Chinese patents now contribute more to China’s technological progress than US patent applications in China.

Technological sovereignty vs. geoeconomic competition

The study further shows that influential patent applications in China are filed more frequently by state-owned enterprises, followed by private enterprises and only then by foreign-invested enterprises. Domestic patents – including contributions from universities and research institutes – outweigh patent applications from abroad in overall significance. A development scenario is emerging in which China is already placing sustained reliance on domestic inventions and is increasingly reducing its dependence on foreign technologies. “On the one hand, this course towards technological sovereignty opens up new opportunities for China, for example through the targeted support of national R&D and production capacities. On the other hand, this also entails considerable challenges from an international perspective – particularly regarding international research collaboration and geoeconomic competition,” Böing explains.