Heat Pumps Are Preferred– but Building Characteristics Matter
ResearchZEW Survey of Energy Experts on Recommendations for Heating System Replacement
For energy experts, the heat pump is the first choice when heating systems need to be replaced. In a nationwide ZEW survey of 2,551 specialists, conducted in 2026, respondents reported having recommended a heat pump in 71 per cent of cases on average in 2025.
Among HVAC installers, heat pumps accounted for an average of 57 per cent of the heating systems installed. In a supplementary experiment involving realistic advisory scenarios, heat pumps were also recommended in around two-thirds of cases.
“The experts see the greatest obstacles to renewable heating technologies not so much in the technology itself as in the frequent changes in the policy framework, the high investment costs and the lack of financial resources among customers,” says study co-author Professor Kathrine von Graevenitz, PhD, deputy head of ZEW’s Research Unit “Environmental and Climate Economics”. She adds: “From the experts’ perspective, what matters most to their customers are the investment costs and long-term total costs, as well as sufficient heating capacity.”
“At the same time, our findings show that it is not only the building’s energy requirements that determine whether a heat pump is recommended. Household income and age, as well as the year the building was constructed, also play a role. This means that a heat pump recommendation does not depend solely on the building’s energy characteristics,” explains co-author Max Stellbrink, who is a researcher in the same Research Unit. Co-author Bettina Chlond adds: “We also observe clear differences among the experts themselves. Even in comparable advisory situations, they sometimes arrive at different recommendations. In addition, the professional groups studied differ in their expectations regarding future trends in energy prices.”
High investment costs and regulatory changes are holding back the heating transition
Eighty per cent of respondents cite high investment costs as a barrier to renewable heating technologies; 74 per cent mention frequent changes in the regulatory framework; and 72 per cent cite a lack of financial resources among customers. Technical problems, by contrast, play hardly any role; only four per cent mention inadequate product quality. At the same time, more than 90 per cent of experts expect natural gas prices to rise over the next five years, while more than half anticipate that prices for electricity used to power heat pumps will remain stable or fall.
Building condition is key
The study shows how strongly the characteristics of buildings influence recommendations. When the building’s energy demand is lower – 70 rather than 120 kilowatt-hours per square metre – the likelihood of a heat pump recommendation rises by 24.5 percentage points. Conversely, at a higher energy demand of 200 kilowatt-hours per square metre, it falls by 32.7 percentage points. Underfloor heating increases the likelihood of a heat pump recommendation by 19.8 percentage points compared with radiators.
About the study
Around 46,000 energy experts were invited to take part in the study in the summer of 2026. Each participant also assessed six realistic advisory scenarios. This yielded a total of 15,306 recommendations, which were statistically analysed to examine how they relate to building and household characteristics.